Please note: this review contains spoilers of the first season of Shakugan no Shana
Hey, Cedric_alpha is back again. Just like I did before with A Certain Magical Index, I’m reviewing another anime that was showcased on Funimation On-demand, and to prove if this is worthy of being on the Toonami block. Now, unlike the Index/Railgun series, I have seen all of the seasons of this show, so I will have other reviews coming soon for this. I have a lot to say about this series as well, because this was one hell of a roller coaster ride. But for now, I will take you on a tour of the first season of one of the most popular light novel series in Japan. This is my review of the first chapter of Shakugan no Shana.
Story
We start this show off in Misaki City, with a boy talking about how his life was changed on that day. This kid is named Yuji Sakai. He’s just living a normal life, and all is going right, until a giant baby monster and a bunch of heads attack the town, and suck the life force outta people. Yuji looks like he about to die at the hands of the baby monster, until its arm is cut off, and he is freed. The person who did it is a girl with “flaming red hair and blazing eyes.” She defeats the baby monster and attacks the multi-head monster as well, but another one appears, almost attacking Yuji. She cuts its arm off too, and when shes about to kill it, Yuji stops her. Unfortunately for him, the monster attacks Yuji, having her hand go inside him, seemingly looking for something. And then the girl attacks Yuji herself, to stop the monster’s attack.
It’s only a flesh wound
And just like that, Yuji is dead, and the show ends like that. Good night. Time to write another review for another show.
I’m joking of course. The show isn’t over, not by a long shot. But I’m not joking about Yuji. Because Yuji is, in fact, dead. Well, at least the real one is. The monsters, who are called “Rinne,” consumed “the real Yuji,” along with a bunch of others, including his classmate, Yukari Hirai. The girl repairs the town with her powers, and the people there, who are now all “Torches,” temporary replacements for the people consumed by the Rinne. Yuji is said Torch now, along with Hirai. Nothing but a thing. Torches fade away gradually, their existences just disappearing from everyone’s memory. Of course, Yuji is also what they called a “Mystes,” a Torch who has a treasure in him, that transfers from person to person. These Mystes are shaped by the Denizens of the Crimson World, who are the bad guys of this show, and the people who control the Rinne. I’ll get into what the treasure is in a minute. But that girl who attacked him/the Rinne? She is a “Flame Haze,” a person who hunts Denizens down and who has to maintain balance/order from both worlds. This Flame Haze has a companion as well, a talking pendant. Of course, this is no ordinary pendant. Its name is Alastor, the Flame of the Heavens, and it helps this girl out with her duties. It’s revealed later that Alastor is also a Lord of the Crimson World, and opposes Denizens who attack others. The girl is revealed to have no name whatsoever. So, after telling Yuji the name of her sword, “Nietono no Shana,” Yuji decides to name her Shana. And so the adventures of Yuji and Shana start out like that.
After all of this, Shana actually gets into Yuji’s school by replacing Hirai, and taking over her existence. The school sees her as just Hirai. That monster who attacked Yuji, who was actually a doll controlling it, is with its master, who wants to destroy the city and so it can be all Torches, and turn them into power of existence for said doll, because he loves it. Yeah, it’s very creepy. They do attack the school going after Yuji, and basically making all his friends nearly dead. Yuji helps by replenishing his own existence to save them, and as his flame is fading, Shana notices it come back to full. Later, in the battle with the doll fetish pervert, Yuji gets most of his existence taken away again, but as he’s disappearing, midnight strikes, and he’s back to normal, flame replenish again. That treasure I said Yuji has? It’s called the “Midnight Lost Child” and if Yuji loses some or most of his existence, he gets it back at midnight. It’s a Deus Ex Machina really. They do show later on Shana using this treasure of his to test her power and him getting his flame back at midnight.
That doll fetish guy, whose name is Hunter Friagne, by the way, is still a menace, but they do finish him off (and I should point out, he got beaten pretty quickly too). But right after he gets beat, they face another Flame Haze, named Margery Daw, The Chanteror of Ellargies (I think they made up these words, but it’s used in the dub). She uses her flying book partner Marchosias (Or Marcho, for short), the Claws and Fangs of Violation (Yes, they all have names like this) and fight to protect her from beating a Crimson Denizen named Lamis, The Corpse Collector, who takes all the Torches who are dying, and turns them into power of existence for himself, for a good cause. Margery hates all Denizens, even ones who help out like Lamis, and will kill him just out of hatred/revenge for what a Denizen named Silver did to her. Of course, Shana, with Yuji’s help, beats Margery (but doesn’t kill her) and Lamis escapes, only before giving a hint that Yuji’s treasure has more to it that it seems. But that’s for the other seasons.
I lost to that tsundere loli. Does anyone have a drink?
Then the show gets all romantic and crap and throws in a love triangle angle. It’s the worst part of the show, by a long shot. Shana does get feelings for Yuji early on, and it shows. A LOT. But so does another girl named Yoshida, who catches those feels for Yuji. She is not the violent tsundere like Shana is. She’s the shy type like Hinata from Naruto. Although unlike Hinata, she isn’t powerful and … actually revealing anything right now will spoil the 2nd and 3rd seasons, so I’ll save my words about Yoshida for now. Just know that Yoshida is Shana’s rival in trying to get Yuji’s attention. There are also more Crimson Denizens that show up. Namely twin brother and sister that are named Tiriel and Sorath. And they make out with each other, with tongue, more than once. Don’t worry, I’ll give you a minute to barf out your lunch. Take your time. Unless you’re used to it because anime/are into this sort of thing. Which if the latter, yuck. There’s also the guy who kinda supervises them, but also couldn’t care what they do. His name is Sydonay, Thousand Changes, but he’s more important later on, so I’ll get to him soon. The twins do attack the city, and are after Shana for her sword to collect. They kiss in front of her too, which makes her cringe (like the rest of us), mostly because she was told “a kiss is an oath” by Yuji’s mom, and this just pisses her off. She does get stronger with Yuji by her side, including starting to fly, and the twins get done in anyway. There’s a sword the male twin has called “Bloodsucker,” that can hurt others by not even touching you. Just know that.
After all of this, Shana actually gets into Yuji’s school by replacing Hirai, and taking over her existence. The school sees her as just Hirai. That monster who attacked Yuji, who was actually a doll controlling it, is with its master, who wants to destroy the city and so it can be all Torches, and turn them into power of existence for said doll, because he loves it. Yeah, it’s very creepy. They do attack the school going after Yuji, and basically making all his friends nearly dead. Yuji helps by replenishing his own existence to save them, and as his flame is fading, Shana notices it come back to full. Later, in the battle with the doll fetish pervert, Yuji gets most of his existence taken away again, but as he’s disappearing, midnight strikes, and he’s back to normal, flame replenish again. That treasure I said Yuji has? It’s called the “Midnight Lost Child” and if Yuji loses some or most of his existence, he gets it back at midnight. It’s a Deus Ex Machina really. They do show later on Shana using this treasure of his to test her power and him getting his flame back at midnight.
After the twins are done, we get a flashback to Shana past, before she became the Flaming Hair, Blazing Eyes Hunter. She is training at the Palace of Heaven’s Road, a giant palace in the sky, with a skeleton, who’s a warrior named Shiro. There is also a Flame Haze maid there who is mostly Shana’s guardian. She is Wilhelmina Carmel, The Specialist of Everything, with her partner Tiamat, The Tiara of Dreams and Illusions, who is, well a tiara on Wilhelmina’s head. Indeed, she mostly takes care of Shana, but she indeed does kick ass in her own way too, indeed. (If you’re wondering why I’m saying “indeed,” this is Wilhelmina’s word to say on there in the 1st series. Like Naruto’s “Believe it!,”but less annoying. Or maybe more. Depends on how you feel). Anyway, a couple of Crimson Denizens attack, and one of them, who is a motorcycle rider, is looking for the palace for a group of 3 called Bal Masqué. Bal Masqué includes Sydonay, who I mentioned a minute ago. The other Denizen, who is just floating Shakespearean-esque clothes, attacks Wilhelmina when she is searching for Melon Bread for Shana. They are about to battle, but a big samurai dude named Tenmoko Ikko, who is a Mystes and the “Strongest Torch,” interrupts and fights flying clothes guy. Back at the palace, Shana wants to beat Shiro in battle, and comes up with a way involving ketchup. This somehow leads to him getting a PTSD moment (I’m assuming the ketchup reminds him of blood), going bat-shit crazy and with a rainbow burst of light, causes the palace to be un-hidden and motorcycle dude to get there. Tenmoko Ikko also gets there and a big fight ensues that is destroying the palace. Samurai dude wants to fight a warrior of great strength, and Shana promises that fight. She forms her contract with Alastor there and becomes the Flame Haze. (There’s a flashback within this flashback that shows Alastor’s former Flame Haze, who looks like an older Shana, that tells what happened back then and how anyone who makes a contract with Alastor will eventually die. Beause Flame Hazes are immortal or something and have to fight Denizens for the rest of time till they get killed). She does fight Tenmoko Ikko, as well as a got-his-body-back-for-some-reason Shiro, and proves herself to be a sure-fire Flame Haze before the palace falls into the seas. Wilhelmina and Shana then part ways. Even though Shana’s still a kid, but you know, them the Flame Haze rules.
The last part of the story takes place during the Misago Festival in the city and is the longest part of the 1st season. Again, there are more romantic subplots taking place during it, like Shana not knowing her feelings, and Yoshida trying to tell Yuji hers. And other characters with feelings for others (I’ll talk more about this in the character section.) But enough of that for now. Bal Masqué is making their move and it involves Yuji, and the Midnight Lost Child in him. Another Flame Haze, who has the body of a 12 year old Indian boy, but is called “an old geezer,” also arrives. He is Khamsin, Mobilizer of Ceremonial Equipment, and his partner, Behemoth, Steadfast Sharp Peak, and his plan is to map out the city of Misaki. He needs help with this, and gets it in Yoshida, who he shows the world of the Flame Hazes/Crimson Denizens to, and Yoshida discovers that Yuji is dead/a Torch and Shana is also a Flame Haze. Wilhelmina returns and knows about the MLC and wants to kill the Mystes who has it. Big problem being that is Shana’s love interest. She almost does it, by the way, but Shana stops her. Yuji also wants to leave the city with Shana so that he can protect the city, his friends, and his mom from the enemies after the MLC in him. Yuji is also being the Dense MC because he doesn’t know Shana loves him (again, ALL OVER HER FACE!!), or might think she does, but Shana can’t comprehend what love is and she tsunderes him away. And Yoshida finally tells him he loves her after finding out he’s a Torch and says he’s human. I hate this romantic triangle crap!! Sorry, it’s true. I just can’t stand it here.
So the festival is getting attacked (all of what I said in the previous paragraph happens before/during this attack) and Bal Masqué is behind it. A Denizen/crazy guy named The Seeker, sometimes being called The Professor, and his robotic Rinne Domino are using the bird statues all over the festival and city to do stuff. He attacks with a blimp too, but Shana, Margery, and Khamsin stop him. He flees, but the next day Yuji senses something wrong with the remaining birds. At the Palace of the Stars, Bal Masqué base of operations, Bel Peol, Judge of Paradoxes, the 3 eyed busty Crimson Lord, has a plan to create “a fount of existence.” Supreme Throne Hecate, the turquoise haired loli, thinks the MLC will help fulfill her desires. Sydonay wants to protect “his pure Hecate,” and keep her pure throughout. Geez, I wonder what other J.C. Staff anime I saw recently involved “a pure girl” and someone wanting her to stay pure? (If you know what show I’m referring to, just know this show doesn’t go THAT far, like in that show.) Those remaining bird statues? They get burned during a ceremony, and it turns into an unrestricted method, which you’ll hear a lot of times in the series, and Bal Masqué attacks. They are after Yuji, of course, and Wilhelmina decides he needs to die. But Shana gets in the way of her attack, is injured badly, and Yuji is kidnapped to the Palace.
Bal Masqué wants to use Yuji, or more specifically, the MLC for this “fount of existence.” Yuji starts to forget who he is because of Hecate. She is taking all of his memories and using them to “fulfill herself,” If you watch this, it really sounds like they’re having sex, like it was made out to be from a bad doujinshi. This whole thing with her taking his memories just sounds like unintentional double entendres. Her moaning doesn’t help things either. On to the story again, the power of existence going from Yuji himself is exiting the palace and on to the city, which is overwhelming it. Shana, recovered from her injuries, and Wilhelmina fly into the palace and are attacked by a ton of Domino clones. They get their existence drained by one of the Professor’s experiments. (He’s also running the system that’s taking Yuji’s existence and hitting the city, even if Hecate’s is the core of it.) Margery does help and take out the system and the duo destroys the clones. Shana sets off for Yuji, declaring her feelings for him finally.
There are other fights as Sydonay and Margery fight each other, and Wilhelmina and Bel Peol square off too. Shana finds Yuji in a Star Wars-like crystallize form. But Yuji is still fighting himself, and him remember Shana, knowing Hecate is nothing but a shell, and he declaring himself to be the Yuji Sakai, help him too. Shana throwing Bloodsucker at his body to free him also helps. Of course it’s not over as Hecate has a “unlimited amount of power of existence.” But because she got broken with that empty shell talk, it pours out, getting the city even more to near destruction. The only way to save the city is to have Alastor manifest himself and Shana to die because of this. Yuji can’t be saved in time, so he decides to die with her, and as she lets out Alastor’s full power, she tells Yuji she loves him. Then KABOOM!!!! Bye-Bye palace. All Bal Masqué members escape though, and it looks like the two died. But they didn’t. They are still alive because Shana’s body could handle Alastor’s power, and from the ring Yuji took from Friagne earlier, which can stop fire attacks. I don’t know how a tiny ring stopped all that, but anime logic persists that it did. And so we end with our heroes happy and alive.
Characters
Now that I got the story finally out of the way, I can now go on to the characters. I mentioned most, but there still are some I have to get to, so bare with me. I already mentioned Shana enough. I’ll admit she is a very cute character, who loves her melon bread. Did I forget to mention that she loves melon bread?
She might love this stuff more than she loves Yuji
Of course her cuteness is taken down a hundred pegs by her being ONE OF THE BIGGEST TSUNDERES IN ANIME EVER! I seen lots of tsunderes before in anime. We all have. Shana is up there with the best/worst of them. Depending on how you feel about tsunderes, she can get very annoying, very fast. Although, I’ll also admit her “Shut Up, Shut Up, Shut Up!” line is the cutest tsundere thing she says. Her partner Alastor is basically her guidance, and kinda like a grandfather figure more than anything. Alastor knows she has a job to do, but Alastor still learns that her feelings get in the way. Alastor is hesitant about these things as well for Alastor doesn’t know emotions as well, but does get curious and tries to learn as best he can. I basically told everything about Yuji and how dense he can get. There’s still more about Yuji that I haven’t said, but that stuff doesn’t happened till the next two seasons, so I’ll hold off on it. I also said most of what I have to about Kazumi Yoshida, and her rivalry with Shana and feeling for Yuji, so enough about her. Like Yuji, she has more things I’ll tell you in my next review.
Now to others that are part of the story I didn’t talk about. There are two guys on here, Keisaku Satou and Eita Tanaka, who at the beginning are “the toughs” of the school, and yet might actually get the most character development out of the people who aren’t the MCs. They get introduced early to the world of the Flame Hazes and Crimson Denizens, thanks to Margery Daw. And they actually do help their “Big Sister” a few times. Be it finding Tourches or Denizens through the use of the Crystal Altar, a tool Friagne used (the doll fetish guy had a bunch of useful stuff the others use once he’s gone) to just being where the action is happening. They do want to get stronger, to catch up to Margery when she gonna leave them, and it shows when they try to lift Bloodsucker to no avail, which Shana and Margery can lift easily. I guess Keisaku and Eita can’t lift, bruh. (Yeah, sorry for that.) Margery herself, when not fighting Flame Hazes or Denizens, just drinks. And boy does she drink. She drinks alot to the point of passing out anywhere, even at a pool. Marcho, her partner, is usually honest about everything she says/does, and gets a beating from her because of it. Marcho’s also honest about others, mostly making fun of them though.
Others people on there include Hayato Ike. He is Yuji’s best friend, and he has feelings for Yoshida. There’s also Yukari Hirai, and as said, she didn’t last long. She did have feelings for Ike, which Yuji noticed. But he didn’t notice Shana’s feelings for him. Dense MC is always dense. Matake Ogata is a girl on here, and she doesn’t do much. She does have feeling for Eita, though, and actually tells him that. Everyone gets to love on this show. And there’s Chigusa Sakai, Yuji’s lovely mother, who does actually help Shana through her feelings with Yuji, and actually supports the relationship. That’s as least what I can tell. I could talk more about Lamis and Khamsin, but they have only 15 minutes of fame, and don’t appear again till Season 3. Bal Masqué I gave in detail in story, but know there’s more from them in the next series as well. And for Wilhelmina? She cool, but really brash, and decides things for herself. Just thinking what is best right away. Also this is not really anything, but I’ll point it out. She wears … Bloomers!
I’m so sorry. I had to.
Animation
Now, as I said with Index, Shana is made by the same animation studio, J.C. Staff. I said in that review that J.C. Staff, while not the most pretty of the bunch, was the most consistent, making very few mistakes. Well, while I still believe this, there are always exceptions, especially with earlier anime. Shana has a lot of problems, mostly around with how character designs around the face area. Here’s one example.
Probably not the best example, but if you can see the background characters, they are not the best looking. There are more examples in the show where a lot of people have derpy moments on them, and it just looks bad. Even the main characters up close get pretty bad looks a few times. Now, I know this is from 10 years ago, but I’m pretty sure that has nothing to do with it, as recent animes have looked so much worst. Also to note, when the Flame Hazes/Denizens put up the “Seals,” the things they use to fight in that stop time and space, the color shading is a bit too dark at times, and it does look a bit ugly. But while it does have these issues, this animation overall still looks good. Pretty top notch. Looking at Shana’s hair glow with the color of fire looks pretty, especially with the chard embers coming off her too. The city and palaces looks beautiful. Not spectacular by any measures, but overall well done. I may have dumped on the faces of the characters, but overall, they look good, when not derpy. The action is well made, and the CGI does look good here, with Shana’s hair and the unrestricted methods moving about, considering the time it was made. The animation may not be perfect, but overall, it gets a passing grade.
English Dub
Now before I get to this, just know; The first season, even though it’s currently licensed by Funimation, actually still used the Ocean dub for it. Season 2 and 3 use the Texas Funimation actors for them. So if you watch both 1 and 2 right away like I did on-demand, yeah, it sounds weird hearing new voices and might take awhile to get used to. Again, I will get to that in my next review, but I’m here to talk about the Ocean dub’s voice actors for now. The title character in the first season is voiced by Tabitha St. Germain. Now if that name sounds familiar, she voices the fabulous pony Rarity on My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic. (Yeah I watched it. So what? Wanna fight about it?!) And if even if you don’t watch the ponies, that’s okay. She’s been on Toonami before. Very recently in fact as the psycho-maid Roberta on Black Lagoon, and on past Toonami shows like Gundam Seed, Inuyasha, and even Hamtaro. Here, she plays the tsundere loli pretty well throughout, but there are times when her character sounds a bit off. Like the voice is a bit to fast, or a bit too high pitched at times. But mostly, she’s okay. Now for Shana’s partner, Alastor, he’s my favorite voice actor on this show. Alastor is voiced by Paul Dobson, or as you mostly know him as the vile villain Naraku on Inuyasha. He has appeared also on Black Lagoon, DBZ, Gundam, and … Lego Ninjago?! (Look it up. It’s true.) Anyway, he brings the best out of this character, commands this performance, and sounds perfect for a being who’s suppose to be very powerful. As for Yuji, he’s voiced by Kristian Ayre. And while I don’t know much about the actor, he does great as Yuji here. He does give a great performance fitting to character going through all the things Yuji goes through, so I commend him for that.
The others voices I like I here are Janyse Jaud and Trevor Devall, who voice Margery Daw and Marchosias, respectively. (The former having played Kagura in Inuyasha, and Sarah and Lee Kanker on Ed, Edd, n’ Eddy. The latter also voicing Friagne on here and later voicing the dog on Johnny Test.) They’re the best duo on here in terms of going back and forth at each other, and showing the relationship of the partners they voiced. I could watch Marcho all day complain about Margery’s drinking then get punched for it and have her spin him around in her drunken stupor. Same when they fight as one being and destroy everything. They have the best chemistry of all the characters on here. Another voice I like is Keisaku, as he is voiced by Brad Swaile. You know him well at Light on Death Note and Rock on Black Lagoon. Even though he isn’t the main on here like he is on the other shows, he’s still great as Keisaku.
Other voice actors on here include Brenna O’ Brien, Eli Gabay, and Paula Lindbjerg as Bal Masqué members Hecate, Sydnonay, and Bel Peol (The 1st person listed voices Rin on Inuyasha. Can you tell how much I like that show?), Chantal Strand (Yoshida), Alistair Abell (Eita), Anna Cummer (Wilhelmina), Matthew Erickson (Ike), Lalainia Lindbjerg (Yuji’s mom) Ron Halder (Lamis), and Cathy Weseluck and Ashleigh Bell voicing Khasmin and Hirai, respectively. (The former voicing Spike and the latter voicing Applejack and Rainbow Dash on MLP:FIM.) This is a great talent of actors on here. And because of that, the dub sounds really good. One of the highlights for me of this show.
Indeed, you will fight me. And you will lose, indeed.
Music
While the in-show music is not really much all that special, I will say the church choir music they play usually at the beginning is pretty good. But other than that, not much to excite you. Now for the 1st OP, it’s actually great, and one of my favorite OPs of the Shana series
(Sorry, but the Youtube part messed up copying this. Go look it up on Youtube or Soundcloud. Yeah, I’m that fucking lazy. Deal with it.)
“Hishoku no Sora” by Mami Kawada is one of the best I heard throughout in this series. In fact, I even jammed to this before shoveling snow and wishing I had her fire power to melt it all. Winters does that to you. Anyway, the second OP, “Being” by Kotoko, is pretty impressive itself. In fact, you might like it more. But I really like the 1st one better. The EDs, just as with the OPs, I like the first ED, “Yoake Umarekuru Shojo” by Yoko Takahashi more than the second ED, “Aka no Seijaku” by Yoko Ishida. Again, your taste will differ in which in better, especially since the 2nd ED is really chill sounding. Overall, they’re not bad. Good music to listen to.
Should this be on Toonami?
Now my final thoughts on the first Shana season has to end with the obvious question: Is this show suitable for Toonami? My response: I believe so. Now, there are some factors going against it. One of the main ones is its age. The show is 10 years old. Jason DeMarco has stated that older shows, or shows that are kinda old like this,don’t have a good shot of making it on Toonami, unless they are old popular ones like Bebop, Inuyasha, and FLCL. Although, to be fair to Shakugan no Shana, Tenchi Muyo GXP made it on the new Toonami and that show came out in 2002. But DeMarco’s statement was way different after that show ended, so who knows. Also, the age of this does show. It did get a nice Blu-Ray touch up, so if it does have any chance, they might use that. Another factor is that romance part of it. I know the Toonami audience can get used to romances on here, as there’s been a few, but the romance on here is a big factor. It annoyed me a bunch. I wonder how much it would annoy the audience. Would they like the love triangle? Would they love the other romances? Will they hate the guts out of the incest love? (I really hope so.) Also, will they like a tsundere female MC, who stays that way through the whole show? I seen the faithful’s reactions to other tsunderes, and it is mixed, to say the least. Now, one thing I haven’t mention is that there is some fanservice in this show as well, mostly involving Shana herself. I don’t know how people will take that either, since (and sorry about this SAO fans) she is more of a flat pancake than Sinon is. They do showcase her loli-like body a lot, along with some random panty shots thrown in for good measure. Some may like this, some will hate it. The show still has a lot of action. It takes some breaks with the romance, and love, and dealing with death, but between that, the action is solid throughout, and there’s enough of it to warrant a Toonami run. And it helps being 24 episodes, a good number for a run. So if they wanted to show it, they could.
Final Thoughts
To close, does Shakugan no Shana have issues? Yes. But so do a lot of shows. The romance can get annoying, and the animation can look bad, but with a ton of action, a pretty-kick butt (if very tsundere) female MC, and some characters that can be pretty fun, this show does get my stamp of being Toonami worthy. I’ll be back next time soon for my review of Shakugan no Shana the Second. And just like this one, I got a lot of things to say about it too.
6.5 “Shut Up, Shut Up, Shut Up!’s”/10
(Shakugan no Shana is animated by the studio J.C. Staff. The anime is licensed by Funimation Entertainment.)